Here we go again

In a recent edition of the New England Journal of Medicine there were two original articles and an editorial discussing a large placebo controlled, randomised study of 25,871 people in the United States using what is known as a 2 X 2 factorial design which involved Fish oil, Vitamin D and placebo. There were four possible combinations i.e. Fish oil/placebo; Fish oil/Vitamin D; Vitamin D/placebo; double placebo.

image source:

The participants in the treatment arm received fish oil in a dose of 1 g per day which included 840 mg of Omega 3. The dose of Vitamin D was 2000 international units. The study went for just over five years and the participants involved were males over 50 and females over 55 who had no prior history of heart disease or cancer.

The headlines in the popular media basically said Vitamin D, Fish Oil supplements are of little benefit to heart health. I wrote an article a few months ago on a large meta-analysis of 79 trials suggesting that fish oil was of no benefit for the prevention of heart disease involving around 112,000 participants.

The new study basically showed that the trial failed to reach its primary endpoints which were a combination of major cardiovascular events and invasive cancer. Or in other words, taking Fish Oil in the dose administered in the trial along with a modest dose of Vitamin D for just over five years didn’t appear to prevent much in the way of our common killers.

As I have stated in my previous blogs, you cannot take any short-term evidence i.e. five years or less as proof for lack of benefit for supplementation. These studies reinforce this point but say nothing about the long-term benefits of regular supplementation. Interestingly, in this trial there was a 28% reduction in non-fatal heart attack in the people taking the omega three preparation and a very difficult to explain 77% reduction in heart attack in the African-American population.

Thus, these particular trials will not stop me recommending Omega 3 and Vitamin D because all of the indirect evidence points to low Vitamin D levels being associated with a number of diseases and good doses of Omega 3 have been very beneficial for cardiovascular disease, albeit not showing reduction in cardiac death in the short-term but the encouraging trend in the reduction in heart attack even over the short five year period. A large meta-analysis published in Mayo Clinic Proceedings in January 2017, again showed no benefit from Omega 3 supplements in the short term but an 18% reduction in cardiovascular events in trials over five years.

Interestingly, at the recent American Heart Association meeting there was a presentation using a pure form of Omega 3 supplementation, known as Icosapent Ethyl (Vascepa) 4GMS daily in 8,179 people with either existing heart disease (70% of those in the trial) or at high risk for the disease which did appear to have dramatic effects in reducing cardiovascular disease in people already well treated with other cardiovascular medications. The dose of omega 3 used was much higher than used in the trials mentioned above and all the people in the trial had high triglyceride levels which is another blood fat. This trial which went for just under five years, showed a 25% reduction in all major cardiac events.

Also, a large meta-analysis of 70 trials published as a Cochrane review headed by Prof Philippa Middleton from Adelaide has suggested that commencing Omega 3 fatty acids at the 12 week mark in pregnancy reduces the risk for a premature birth (less than 37 weeks) by 11%, 42% reduction for a premature birth less than 34 weeks and the risk for a small baby by 10%. The review suggested that the dose of Omega 3 needs to be somewhere between 500 mg-1000 mg daily, with at least 500 mg of the specific Omega 3, DHA.

There are a variety of other benefits for Omega 3 fatty acids but as I constantly say we must be in this for the long haul. If you wish to take supplements, whether they be a multivitamin, Omega 3s or any other supplement that has a reasonable evidence base, taking it for a few years will not have a particularly long-term impact on your health. It’s a bit like diet and exercise-being on a diet for a few months or exercising for a few months is of no real value, it must, and should be, a lifelong commitment.



Dr Walker is an expert in the field of preventative cardiology and has published seven books. He gives lectures nationally and internationally.

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Dr Ross Walker

Dr Walker is an expert in the field of preventative cardiology and has published seven books. He gives lectures nationally and internationally.